New American Strategies
for Security and Peace
Conference Transcripts:
Final Remarks - Dick Leone
You can now watch this speech in streaming video:

Download this speech in
MS Word format.
Download this speech in Acrobat
(pdf) format.
Thank you, John. This is on the theory that I was paying
attention. It’s impossible to summarize what happened
at this conference. We did learn that there is an appetite
for conversations of this type and a deep commitment
to developing counter-arguments and assessing where
we’ve gone right and where we’ve gone wrong.
There were some sharp disagreements obviously although
I think the overall assessment is an impressive amount
of agreement even across party lines.
Many of our speakers talked about the importance of
remembering the first principles of American foreign
policy and multi-nationalism and bipartisanship in these
areas. In addition, I think many of the arguments were
framed in terms of the importance of having an open
debate, not suppressing debate on the basis that it’s
unpatriotic and that that is the key to building and
sustaining the kind of public support we’ll need
over time.
There was an awful lot of emphasis on the fact that
we squandered some opportunities both domestically and
abroad. But that there is still perhaps the potential
to regain some of that momentum and unity. A number
of speakers talked about the problems that emerge when
you build a policy on ideology. Senator Clinton was
the most recent this morning.
I think in addition last night’s incredible
speech by Zbigniew Brzezinski brought home something
that I hadn’t thought much about that the nation
is at risk of one of those crises of confidence and
trust that we’ve had periodically in our history
during the McCarthy era, during the Vietnam War, during
Watergate. The damage that is done by those of us who
are old enough to remember some of those things that
is done by that kind of problem — far exceeds
any of the brutal bickering or the setbacks that we
see today. I hope that is wrong, but the seeds may well
be there, and it’s a troubling thing indeed.
In addition, focusing on the many references and discussions
of Iraq here we are all seekers together now that we’re
in it whatever we thought beforehand — seekers
of what’s the best policy. Jim Leach proposed
something rather drastic. But I think it was revealing
that it has come to that in his mind. Senator Hagel
talked about a principled realism in dealing with this
kind of an issue.
But one thing is clear. That is the immediate problem
before this government and before this people and that
virtually all of our speakers felt we were going about
it the wrong way these are not snowflake memos we’re
sending out by the way. These are hailstones, we hope,
and they last a little while. In addition, what is always
a sobering discussion of the dangers of weapons of mass
destruction and the inevitability of their becoming
easier to make and the imperative of our finding ways
to make that our top priority, I think remains one of
those subjects to which we must constantly return and
not allow that topic to be obscured by whatever today’s
headlines are about.
We’ve spent a lot of time at The Century Foundation
studying homeland security issues. I wasn’t surprised,
but I guess in an unfortunate way I was reassured to
hear that we’re right when we say we haven’t
done anything like the job we should have done two years
out. I wish I had heard from the people who came to
this conference that we were on the wrong track. I think
we are still on the right track. I think we’re
still on the wrong track.
Finally, I think the final lesson about this is —
most of it’s been criticism of the administration
— is not that they’re bad people but there
are a couple of old lessons we need to remember. That
decency is sadly no substitute for intellect, and ideology
is really no instrument for finding the truth. At the
end of the day careful analysis, an open mind, a liberal
interpretation of what participation involves and what
arguments are relevant are more likely to lead us to
truth. The truth is a more important value even than
loyalty in public life and in any nation, and the truth
for us now is we have to find a new course and we have
to be open to it. Thank you. (Applause)
|